Bone Broth vs. Collagen—A Nutritionist Settles the Debate

2 weeks ago 21

The elixir of health, beauty, and longevity. A steaming mug of minerals oregon a sleek scoop of protein? These 2 contenders are up for debate: bone broth and collagen. If you’ve wondered which deserves a spot successful your wellness routine, welcome. We’re breaking down the pros and cons of each. While there’s a bully accidental you’ve heard of both, the victor isn’t truthful black-and-white. Whether you’re a wellness newbie oregon a play aficionado, it’s clip to settee the bony broth vs. collagen dispute—once and for all.

These 2 superstars committedness radiant skin, sturdy joints, beardown muscles, and a blessed gut. But which 1 is close for you? Scroll to get the deets. We’re unveiling their benefits, versatility, cost-effectiveness, and more. Time to unlock the secrets to a healthier you.

What is bony broth?

Bone broth is simply a nutrient-rich liquid, derived from simmering carnal bones (typically chicken, beef, oregon fish) on with vegetables, herbs, and spices. It’s a comparatively dilatory and prolonged cooking process. In turn, the bones merchandise their collagen and indispensable nutrients. The result: a savory and aromatic liquid—rich successful spirit and wellness benefits. Bone broth is simply a earthy root of everything from collagen and indispensable amino acids to B vitamins and minerals. This nutrient-dense liquid tin enactment associated function, gut health, and skin appearance.

1 of 7

Woman drinking bony  broth.

What is collagen?

Collagen, connected the different hand, plays a captious relation successful insubstantial enactment (think: skin, joints, and bones). It’s a macromolecule derived from carnal oregon marine sources—cow, chicken, fish, oregon pig collagen. Collagen supplements are disposable successful assorted forms, including powders, capsules, and liquid. Ultimately, they’re designed to beryllium easy incorporated into your daily routine. Collagen is touted for its imaginable to amended tegument elasticity, associated mobility, and gut health.

Are collagen and collagen peptides the aforesaid thing?

Not quite. Collagen peptides are made by breaking down carnal collagen done hydrolysis. So, while collagen is simply a complete protein, collagen peptides are fragments of that protein. Whole collagen is hard for the assemblage to digest oregon absorb, portion collagen peptides are importantly much accessible for the body.

2 of 7

Woman drinking matcha collagen powder.

Why Sourcing Matters

When it comes to bony broth vs. collagen, sourcing is important. After all, pasture-raised and factory-farmed animals are not the same. Pasture-raised carnal products connection superior nutrient profiles compared to their accepted counterparts.

These animals thin to person a fare affluent successful natural, nutrient-dense forage, resulting successful bones and tissues with higher levels of the bully stuff: indispensable vitamins and minerals. Additionally, they person little vulnerability to antibiotics and hormones. Plus, these animals person little of an environmental impact. Moral of the story: erstwhile possible, take pasture-raised!

3 of 7

Bone Broth Thai Chicken Soup

Nutrient Content: Bone Broth vs. Collagen

With nutrient creation successful mind, which comes retired connected top? In presumption of nutrient diversity, bony broth wins. But for concentrated (specific) nutrients, collagen takes the cake.

Bone Broth

  • Pros: Thanks to bony broth’s dilatory cooking process, it’s a multitasker—extracting collagen, amino acids, vitamins, and minerals. It’s a earthy root of multiple nutrients.
  • Cons: The nutrient contented successful bony broth tin alteration (particularly owed to sourcing, bony quality, and simmer time), and it whitethorn not beryllium arsenic concentrated successful circumstantial nutrients arsenic collagen supplements.


  • Pros: Collagen supplements are disposable successful a much concentrated form. They supply a precise dosage of collagen peptides, making it easier to power your intake.
  • Cons: They often deficiency the wide spectrum of nutrients recovered successful bony broth.

Do you sorb bony broth oregon collagen better?

If you privation to get the astir bang of your nutrition buck, it’s important to recognize bioavailability. In essence, bioavailability refers to your body’s quality to sorb and utilize nutrients. When it comes to collagen and bony broth, collagen supplements are designed for amended absorption. In different words, they’re formulated to beryllium highly bioavailable. While this means it’s easier for your assemblage to sorb collagen peptides, it lacks the further nutrients that bony broth contains.

Keep successful caput that different schools of thought reason that due to the fact that bony broth contains collagen successful its earthy form, it’s much readily absorbed than collagen peptides, acknowledgment to the beingness of different co-factors (minerals, amino acids, and vitamins). In summary? The jury’s inactive out.

4 of 7

Woman drinking bony  broth successful  mug.

Is bony broth easier to digest than collagen?

For many, yes! Bone broth is casual to digest owed to its gentle, nourishing properties. It’s often recommended for those with digestive issues. Especially erstwhile aromatics, similar ginger, are added to the simmering liquid, bony broth tin soothe an upset stomach. While consuming it successful excess whitethorn pb to discomfort, that’s rather rare. Collagen supplements are besides well-tolerated, of course, but bloating oregon state tin beryllium a imaginable broadside effect.

How to Add Bone Broth and Collagen to Your Diet

Is 1 much versatile than the other? Not distinctly. Bone broth tin beryllium utilized arsenic a basal for soups, stews, sauces, and sipped connected its own. It adds a extent of spirit and nutrients to assorted dishes. Although preparing it homemade takes time, it’s reasonably debased effort (thanks to a slow-cooker oregon crockpot!). Collagen supplements are besides multipurpose. You tin easy adhd the pulverization to smoothies, teas, lattes, and soups. The unflavored assortment volition person a minimal interaction your recipe’s sensation and texture.

5 of 7

Matcha smoothie_bone broth vs collagen

The Cost Equation

Making homemade bony broth is economical, particularly if you usage leftover bones from meals (like rotisserie chickenhearted oregon bone-in chickenhearted thighs). It’s a sustainable mode to maximize the worth of your ingredients. Plus, if you freeze your fridge scraps implicit time—like bulb peels, carrot tops, and broccoli stalks—a nourishing bony broth comes unneurotic with a minimal, zero-waste cost!

On the flip side, collagen supplements can be much cost-effective. Particularly successful presumption of terms per gram of collagen. After all, you’re paying for the circumstantial nutrient you’re targeting. At the extremity of the day, it’s a flip up.

6 of 7

Sheet cookware  chickenhearted  and veggies_bone broth vs collagen

Bone Broth vs. Collagen: The Takeaway

In the bony broth vs. collagen debate, the champion prime depends connected your idiosyncratic preference. Bone broth offers a broader spectrum of nutrients—and the restitution of a homemade, accepted approach—while collagen supplements supply a much convenient, precise, and bioavailable root of protein. Ultimately, each has its unsocial advantages. With circumstances successful mind, basal your determination connected your circumstantial dietary needs. In galore cases, some supply a well-rounded attack to nourishing your body.